I saw there wasn't any PEC's lately, so I'm starting up a new one!
Simply we will have all the final evo's of all the starter pokemon up to Gen IV.

ROUND ONE
Round 1 will end on Dec 15 (wed) and end on the time of this post.

My vote:
/
Charizard is my favorite starter and rules! / I've never really cared for Empoleon, and Prinplup is 10x cooler.

My vote: up, down.

Ok, here's my vote:
Sceptile / Blastoise
For quite a long time, Sceptile has been my favorite starter. But Blastoise...just look like a big fat turtle to me (sorry to all you Blastoise-lovers out there!)

{torrterra} up/ down

Torrterra has to have one of the better grass combos for the starters.

Infernape... I just dont like the feel of infernape... He feels rushed to me for some reason.

up, down.

/

Typhlosion is my favorite starter of all time; he was my first starter in the first game I ever owned, Gold. Venusaur is a disappointment compared to the other two Gen 1 starters; Charizard and Blastoise are both awesome, but Venusaur has a terribly limited move pool, and disappointing stats.

And GofD, for all the emphasis you put on that "3RD," you could have at least been right, lol; Infernape was only the second Fire/Fighting starter in a row. Typhlosion is pure Fire (which also makes him the most awesome of the Fire starters).

Well, it seems I cant count... how the heck did I graduate from high school then.... Ill fix that now.

I vote for up/ down

Typhlosion is my favourite starter and I just don't like Meganium.

up/{meganium} down.

Favorite would have to be and I never really like

The votes are in!

Poor , he was never even mentioned...

Round 2
Round 2 will end on Dec 18 (Sat) and end on the time of this post.


My Vote:
/
Still voting for Charizard / Now I want Infernape to go. He looks quite ugly. And his stats put Charizard to shame...

up/ down

Torterra- Ive already explained

Venusaur- I really dont like venusaur. I cant us it in battle to well and has a type combo i really dont like.

/

Feraligatr is very cool, Looks predatory
Infernape is a foolish reproduction of blaziken who is much cooler

up/ down

Empoleon is my favourite 4th generation starter. I'm not a big fan of Infernape, just a little on the plain side for me I guess.

Sceptile UP/Blastoise DOWN.
Same as my last vote, I really like cool Sceptile & dislike the fat turtle.

Here's the current results:

/

I will stick with the same vote I made last round. Same reasons as before, Typhlosion is awesome (as well as the only pure-fire type Fire starter), and Venusaur is by far my least favorite of the original 3.

swampert Up I do not know how many times this thing saved my ass/ Damn mixapes in competitive battling infernape down

up and down.
Always liked Blaziken, never Sceptile. Tried a file with it, and if it was a nuzlocke, I'd have did pre-first gym. I'll put it that way. >_>
Edit: there we go, reasons added!

We had some weird results for Round 2.


Yep- we had a 6 Poke tie for immunity.

Round 3
Round 3 will end on Dec 21 (tuesday) and end on the time of this post.
This round unoficially ended on Dec 20.


My Vote:
/
If you want to know why I like Charizard so, he was my first starter in my FireRed game,
and had an invincible moveset of Fly, Cut, Flamethrower, and Blast Burn.
Sorry Venusaur, but he's my least fav of the Kanto starters. Bulbasaur was somewhat cute though.


EDIT! Because of these results, I'm slightly changing the rules for now on (or until this game ends).
If we have a tie for immunity with 5 or more pokes, then NO ONE WILL GET IMMUNITY.
If something like this happens for Elimination, we will instead have a SUDDEN DEATH SHOWDOWN!!!

Another Edit Due to rule changes, this is no longer up.

Blaziken up and Sceptile down.
Blaziken was my first 100 and first pokemon, it always stuck with me. I just never liked Sceptile.

up/ down

Like I said before Typhlosion is one of my favourite starters. I don't like Venasaur, whenever I used it in a game I ended losing a lot and badly.